Assorted Cookie Boxes

from US$23.00

Our bakery-style cookies are baked fresh and crafted for maximum indulgence—golden edges, soft centers, and bold flavor.

Flavor selections are fixed for signature assortments to ensure consistency, freshness, and quality. No customization required.

Minimum order notice: Orders must be placed at least 5 days in advance. Orders placed under 5 days of the event date may be subject to rush fees or cancelation.

Box Selection:

Our bakery-style cookies are baked fresh and crafted for maximum indulgence—golden edges, soft centers, and bold flavor.

Flavor selections are fixed for signature assortments to ensure consistency, freshness, and quality. No customization required.

Minimum order notice: Orders must be placed at least 5 days in advance. Orders placed under 5 days of the event date may be subject to rush fees or cancelation.

Choose from one of our signature assortments, thoughtfully curated to highlight our most-loved flavors:

Half Dozen Signature Assortment: Includes 2 Chocolate Chunk, 2 S’mores, and 2 Butter Toffee cookies
Full Dozen Signature Assortment: Includes 3 Chocolate Chunk, 3 S’mores, 3 Birthday Cake and 3 Butter Toffee cookies
Party Pack (35 cookies): A chef’s assorted selection of our most popular bakery-style cookies—perfect for sharing or events

Cookie Flavors

Smore- A rich, gooey combination of brown sugar cookie dough, melted semi-sweet chocolate, and toasted marshmallow.

Key Lime Bliss- A tangy-tropical fusion of bright key lime cookie dough, topped with a light dollop of coconut milk icing.

Caramel Apple Pie- Spiced cookie dough, loaded with tender granny smith apples, buttery caramel, and cinnamon, finished with pieces of flaky pie crust.

Birthday Cake – A soft and chewy sugar cookie packed with rainbow sprinkles and a hint of vanilla cake, topped with a swipe of our signature vanilla buttercream and confetti sprinkles.

Butter Toffee- A rich, buttery cookie infused with caramelized toffee bits topped with a sprinkle of flaky sea salt.

Brown Butter Chocolate Chunk – A timeless favorite with a Sugar Stuff twist—crispy edges, a chewy center, and loaded with rich, dark and milk chocolate chunks, topped with a sprinkle of flaky sea salt.

Peanut Butter & Jam- A chewy peanut butter cookie dough filled with our house made strawberry jam and gooey marshmallow center.

Georgia Peach Cobbler – A soft, spiced cookie packed with sweet & juicy peach bits and cinnamon, topped with a buttery sugar crumble for a classic cobbler taste in cookie form.

Strawberry Cheesecake – A rich, buttery cookie dough swirled with sweet strawberry jam and topped with creamy cheesecake and golden graham cracker crumble.

Oreo Cheesecake- A rich, buttery cookie dough loaded with crushed Oreo pieces and topped with creamy cheesecake and a sprinkle of chocolate cookie crumbs.

Strawberry Shortcake- A buttery blend of vanilla and strawberry cookie dough, swirled together and rolled in a nostalgic strawberry shortcake crumble for a soft, bakery-style cookie with a sweet, berry-forward finish.